Department of Humanities
Permanent URI for this collectionhttps://repository.chuka.ac.ke/handle/chuka/244
Browse
Recent Submissions
Item Viability of empirical methods in knowledge acquisition: critical analysis of pragmatism and The Duhem-Quine thesis.(Chuka University, 2024) Nzioka John MosuMost Scholars in epistemology have always considered the tripartite conditions (Belief, Justification and Truth) to be sufficient for knowledge, however, the rise of scientific empiricism has raised doubts in certain circles about the necessity and sufficiency of these conditions. In particular, arguments have been raised to demonstrate the impossibility of ever achieving truth of things as they are (correspondence), hence, rendering knowledge by empirical methods impossible. This conclusion seems a contradiction to our claims that we indeed can know by way of these methods. As such, there was need to examine if indeed knowledge of the physical world is possible. The following were the objectives of this research: to critically examine the necessity and sufficiency of Belief, Justification and Truth as conditions for knowledge; to demonstrate science‘s pragmatic adoption of truth and show how it violates the truth condition; to explore the Duhem-Quine thesis and examine its implication to knowledge; and ultimately, determine the possibility of knowledge acquisition through empirical methods. The theoretical framework proposed to address this problem was the Cartesian criterion of truth which involves establishing that propositions are clear and distinct, and the relevance of establishing logical correctness in arguments. The research methodology for this study was qualitative and it involved an examination of texts relevant to the investigation. The findings of the study were that: Firstly, the tripartite conditions are individually and collectively necessary for knowledge, but collectively sufficient for knowledge; secondly, scientific investigation adopts the pragmatic conception of truth. Thirdly, the Duhem-Quine thesis presents a challenge to knowledge acquisition using empirical methods because its theories are under-determined by evidence. As such, the evidence available to researchers is never sufficient to warrant falsification of a theory. Ultimately, the research established that despite the fact that we cannot know things as they are, it is possible to have knowledge of the appearance of these things and our perspectives of them. It is also important to revise the truth condition to make reference to pragmatism and coherence as opposed to correspondence (which cannot be realized by humans). Further, the justification condition should include evidentialism and reliabilism. In conclusion, the study recommended further research examining the compatibility between ‗armchair‘ and empirical research, and how experimental philosophy revolutionizes the role played by intentionality in knowledge acquisition.Item ENGL 381: RESEARCH TECHNIQUES(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-09-01) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem ENGL 352: LANGUAGE IN AFRICA(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-08-30) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem ENGL 221: PHONOLOGY OF ENGLISH(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-11) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem ENGL 103: ORIGIN AND SPREAD OF ENGLISH(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-08-30) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem EDFO 112: SOCIOLOGY OF EDUCATION(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-11) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem EDFO 111: HISTORY OF EDUCATION(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-25) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem ECDI 343: PHYSICS SUBJECT METHODS STREAMS(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem EDCI 333: RELIGIOUS EDUCATION SUBJECT METHODS(2023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem EDCI 332: HISTORY AND GOVERNANCE SUBJECT METHODS(2023-04-12) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem EDCI 211: PRINCIPLES AND THEORY OF CURRICULUM DEVELOPMENT(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-26) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem EDCI 344: METHODS OF TEACHING AGRICULTURE(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem ECDE 448: CHALLENGES OF FAMILY IN A CHANGING SOCIETY(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem PSYC 483: CONSUMER PSYCHOLOGY(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem CDEV 252: SOCIAL MARKETING AND DEVELOPMENT(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-08-31) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem CDEV 250: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ECOTOURISM(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-08-30) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem CDEV 223: PARTICIPATORY METHODOLOGIES IN COMMUNITY(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 2023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem CDEV 0210: FAMILY STUDIES(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 0023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem CDEV 0209: COMMUNITY HEALTH(CHUKA UNIVERSITY, 0023-08-28) CHUKA UNIVERSITYItem CDEV 0141: PRINCIPLES OF DISASTER MANAGEMENT(0023-04-13) CHUKA UNIVERSITY